When you’re craving an amazing slice of pizza, you can’t go wrong with one of these seven old school pizza parlors in Illinois. Tried and true, these historic joints are still in business for a reason, and it’s about time you tasted why.
Better than any chain, these local pizzerias use the best ingredients and offer family-friendly service you’ll never forget. Check them out:
- Schiappa’s
Google Maps
Facebook/Schiappa’s Home to a 40-inch pizza, this local joint has been in business since 1979. It uses fresh ingredients and homemade dough that really make a difference when it comes to the taste. Find pizza, calzones, pasta, strombolis, and a plethora of delicious appetizers at 402 S Madison St., Lebanon, IL 62254.
- Alongi’s Italian Restaurant
Facebook/Alongi’s Italian Restaurant
Facebook/Alongi’s Italian Restaurant In business since 1933, this is certainly one of the more aged old school pizza parlors in Illinois. It was established by Italian immigrants and offers a rustic and authentic experience. Appetizers, salads, pasta, and a wealth of traditional entrees are offered here as well as pizza, calzones, flatbreads, and Italian sandwiches. Find it all at 18 W Main St., Du Quoin, IL 62832.
- Frato’s Culinary Kitchen
Facebook/Frato’s Culinary Kitchen
Facebook/Frato’s Culinary Kitchen What began as a Chicago hot dog stand in the 1970s is now a marvelous pizza joint you have to try. Known for their fabulous mozzarella sticks and one-pound pizza slice, this restaurant also has an old-fashioned interior that guests love. Find this pizzeria at 628 S Roselle Rd., Schaumburg, IL 60193, and learn more here.
- Italian Village Carbondale
Facebook/Italian Village Carbondale
Facebook/Italian Village Carbondale This family-owned joint is one of the best old school pizza parlors in the state because of it’s no-frills atmosphere and incredible outdoor seating. Enjoy everything from pizza to pasta at 405 S Washington St., Carbondale, IL 62901.
- Pequod’s
Google/Pequod’s Pizza
Google/Eric Rettberg With all the great pizza around Chicagoland, some people tend to miss this infamous one. Known for a caramelized crust, the pies at this pizzeria are to-die-for, and they’ve been filling stomachs since 1971. Though there is a location at 2207 N Clybourn Ave., Chicago, IL 60614, there is also one at 8520 Fernald Ave., Morton Grove, IL 60053, which is the original location, so that you don’t have to go all the way into the city to get this crave-worthy pie.
- Il Forno Pizzeria
Google/DeCarlos
Google/Tx travler You can get pizza by the slice at this classic joint. In business since 1953, this place is known for its homemade dough and sausage as well as its laid-back atmosphere. Guests enjoy everything from pasta, chicken, seafood, and salads to pizza and grinders. Find it all at 496 Old Elm Rd., Highland Park, IL 60035.
- Anna’s Pizza
Facebook/Anna’s Pizza, Winnebago,IL
Facebook/Anna’s Pizza, Winnebago,IL One of Illinois’ tiniest pizza parlors, this little-known eatery has some of the best pies in the state. It is a classic joint that has been in business since 1995 and which has already won awards and recognition. Guests enjoy garlic bread, pizza bread, onion rings, several types of fries, wings, Bosco sticks, cheese curds, flat bread pizza, and so much more at 101 S Benton St., Winnebago, IL 61088. Get more information about this restaurant here.
For more exciting pies, check out these six restaurants in Illinois that make the absolute biggest pizzas ever.
Google Maps
Facebook/Schiappa’s
Home to a 40-inch pizza, this local joint has been in business since 1979. It uses fresh ingredients and homemade dough that really make a difference when it comes to the taste. Find pizza, calzones, pasta, strombolis, and a plethora of delicious appetizers at 402 S Madison St., Lebanon, IL 62254.
Facebook/Alongi’s Italian Restaurant
In business since 1933, this is certainly one of the more aged old school pizza parlors in Illinois. It was established by Italian immigrants and offers a rustic and authentic experience. Appetizers, salads, pasta, and a wealth of traditional entrees are offered here as well as pizza, calzones, flatbreads, and Italian sandwiches. Find it all at 18 W Main St., Du Quoin, IL 62832.
Facebook/Frato’s Culinary Kitchen
What began as a Chicago hot dog stand in the 1970s is now a marvelous pizza joint you have to try. Known for their fabulous mozzarella sticks and one-pound pizza slice, this restaurant also has an old-fashioned interior that guests love. Find this pizzeria at 628 S Roselle Rd., Schaumburg, IL 60193, and learn more here.
Facebook/Italian Village Carbondale
This family-owned joint is one of the best old school pizza parlors in the state because of it’s no-frills atmosphere and incredible outdoor seating. Enjoy everything from pizza to pasta at 405 S Washington St., Carbondale, IL 62901.
Google/Pequod’s Pizza
Google/Eric Rettberg
With all the great pizza around Chicagoland, some people tend to miss this infamous one. Known for a caramelized crust, the pies at this pizzeria are to-die-for, and they’ve been filling stomachs since 1971. Though there is a location at 2207 N Clybourn Ave., Chicago, IL 60614, there is also one at 8520 Fernald Ave., Morton Grove, IL 60053, which is the original location, so that you don’t have to go all the way into the city to get this crave-worthy pie.
Google/DeCarlos
Google/Tx travler
You can get pizza by the slice at this classic joint. In business since 1953, this place is known for its homemade dough and sausage as well as its laid-back atmosphere. Guests enjoy everything from pasta, chicken, seafood, and salads to pizza and grinders. Find it all at 496 Old Elm Rd., Highland Park, IL 60035.
Facebook/Anna’s Pizza, Winnebago,IL
One of Illinois’ tiniest pizza parlors, this little-known eatery has some of the best pies in the state. It is a classic joint that has been in business since 1995 and which has already won awards and recognition. Guests enjoy garlic bread, pizza bread, onion rings, several types of fries, wings, Bosco sticks, cheese curds, flat bread pizza, and so much more at 101 S Benton St., Winnebago, IL 61088. Get more information about this restaurant here.
If you know of any other old school pizza parlors in the state, we’d love to hear from you. Share your favorite historic pizzerias with us below in the comments.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
